Simplify questions and data statements
Last updated: 23 Nov 2008
You will find that the question and data statements are sometimes written in a way which deliberately obscures a fairly simple meaning.
In these cases you will find it useful to simplify the statements or question to make it clearer what information you are provided or what the question you are asked is.
Example problem to simplify
If n is a positive integer, is ?
- n > 2
- Statement (1) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not sufficient
- Statement (2) ALONE is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not sufficient
- BOTH statements TOGETHER are sufficient, but NEITHER statement ALONE is sufficient
- EACH statement ALONE is sufficient
- Statements (1) and (2) TOGETHER are NOT sufficient
Have a go at this question before reading the explanation below.
Simplify the question
The question in this problem can be simplified.
If n is a positive integer, is?
Firstly we can express both sides of the inequality in similar ways because we know that
So we can write the question as
But since the bases for both exponents are the same this can be simplified further to just compare the powers.
Which means can simplify what looks like quite a complex question to, "If n is a positive integer, is n > 3?"
Simplify the data statements
We can also simplify the first data statement
If we take cube roots of both sides of the equation we get
Statement 2 cannot be simplified further
Solve the problem
Once you have simplified this data sufficiency problem it is easy to solve
Statement 1 tells you which is greater than 3 and so is sufficient to answer the question.
Statement 2 tells you that which is insufficient to answer the question.
Therefore the answer is A.
If n is larger than 2, and n is an integer. . wouldn't that make it 3 or bigger? Then wouldn't this be enough info to solve question for statement 2?
You know that n is an integer and n > 2 and you need to know whether n > 3.
There are two possibilities n is 3 in which case it IS NOT greater than 3 or n is 4 or more in which case it IS greater than 3.
Therefore statement 2 is not enough to answer the question.
why isnt it n LESS THAN 3, why is it n GREATER THAN 3
I agree, n should be LESS THAN 3.