Primary purpose explanation

Last updated: 13 Oct 2008

Now you have had a go at this question let us work through the answer together.

Great news for Star Trek fans: warp drives that can propel starships around the Galaxy faster than the speed of light may be possible after all--with a little help from Dr Who. In 1994 Miguel Alcubierre, then at the University of Wales in Cardiff, startled physicists by showing that the starship Enterprise's famed faster-than-light propulsion system might not be so ludicrous after all. Alcubierre proposed that a starship could "warp" space so that it shrinks ahead of the vessel and expands behind it. By pushing the departure point many light years backwards while simultaneously bringing destinations closer, the warp drive effectively transports the starship from place to place at faster-than-light speeds.

But in 1997 Michael Pfenning and Larry Ford at Tufts University in Medford, Massachusetts, apparently killed this ingenious idea by showing that it needed far more than the entire energy content of the Universe to work. Now Chris Van Den Broeck of the Institute for Theoretical Physics at the Catholic University of Leuven, Belgium, has resurrected Alcubierre's proposal. The trick lies in using a strange form of warped space, involving a "bubble" with a large internal volume but a tiny surface area.

To picture how it works, first imagine space having just two dimensions. Then suppose there is a bubble which is connected to this flat space by a very thin neck. Inhabitants of this two-dimensional world would find that this neck has a very small circumference, but the inside of the bubble has a large surface area. In the real world, says Van Den Broeck, these 2D circumferences become surface areas and surface areas become volumes: "You can have regions of space that appear small from the outside, but have huge internal volumes."

Science fiction fans will instantly recognise this as one of the key properties of Dr Who's Tardis, which looked like a police box but had a spacious interior. But the real appeal of such bubbles is that their small surface area can be created with very modest amounts of energy. In his paper, published on the Los Alamos general relativity pre-print service, Van Den Broeck uses Pfenning and Ford's results to show that a bubble big enough to contain a starship could be formed using just a gram of suitable space-warping material. And with the space warped conveniently around the ship, once again destination and departure are brought together, allowing the ship to move faster than the speed of light.

Van Den Broeck cautions that this space-warping material must possess negative energy--and no one knows how to make such material at present. Even so, the discovery that warp drives may not need vast amounts of energy is already causing a flurry of excitement among theorists. "This is a beautiful result", says Alcubierre, who is now at the Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics in Potsdam, Germany. "Of course, there are still some basic questions--like how does one go about constructing this Tardis space-time--but it puts the concept of space warps back on the agenda."

'Warp Factor One', by Robert Matthews, first appeared in New Scientist on 12th June, 1999 and is reprinted with their kind permission.

The primary purpose of this passage is to

  1. discuss the importance of the television program Star Trek for the international space program
  2. discuss important theoretical work concerned with faster-than-light space travel
  3. explore a dispute among theoretical physicists regarding the uses of space flight
  4. describe the possible uses of space-warping material
  5. explain how a space-warping bubble would work in the real world

Explanation

This is a primary purpose question, so we have to determine what the author is trying to do or say in this passage.

Reread relevant sections of the passage 

So, let's read the first and last lines of the passage in order to get an idea of the primary purpose.

The first line says "Great news for Star Trek fans: warp drives that can propel starships around the Galaxy faster than the speed of light may be possible after all--with a little help from Dr Who."

The last line is a quote by a physicist that says "Of course, there are still some basic questions--like how does one go about constructing this Tardis space-time--but it puts the concept of space warps back on the agenda."

From both these sentences, we get the idea of space travel, faster than light travel and space warps - maybe this is a discussion of faster than light space travel.

Does that match what you have already read? Yes, basically this is a discussion of the theoretical state of play in the area of faster-than-light space travel.

Can you find an answer which matches? 

Do any of the 5 answer choices match that? Yes - B, even if the wording is somewhat different from how we are wording it, the idea is almost exactly the same.

B is the answer.

By process of elimination 

Another way of getting to the answer is through elimination of obviously incorrect answer choices.

We can eliminate A because the author mentions the popular science fiction program Star Trek merely to introduce the idea of faster-than-light travel, and nothing more.

C is a stronger possibility because the second paragraph of the passage does discuss some disagreement among physicists about the possibility of creating a warp-drive, but in the same paragraph the theoretical dilemma seems resolved. Moreover, since the author only discusses this in one paragraph, it cannot be the primary purpose of the entire passage.

We can eliminate D because the author does not go into detail discussing the uses of space-warping material.

And we can discard E because the author does not really go into how the space-warping bubble would work in the real world.

 

Next page: Title questions

You must log in or register to add a comment.